Skip to content Skip to footer

When Dentists Recommend Inlays Instead of Fillings or Crowns

Most people are familiar with dental fillings. Many have heard of crowns.
But when a dentist recommends an inlay, it might be the first time you’ve heard the term.

This article explains what an inlay is, when it’s used, and why it can make sense as a middle option between a filling and a crown.


What an Inlay Is, in Simple Terms

An inlay is a custom-made restoration that fits into a damaged area of a tooth.

It’s used when a tooth has more damage than a small filling can safely handle, but doesn’t need to be completely covered by a crown.

Instead of being placed directly into the tooth like a filling, an inlay is made outside the mouth and then bonded into place. This allows it to fit very precisely and support the tooth where it’s weakest.

You can think of it as reinforcing the tooth—without reshaping the entire tooth.


Why a Filling Isn’t Always the Best Choice

Fillings work very well for small areas of decay. As the damaged area gets larger, the remaining tooth structure can become weaker.

Dentists may hesitate to place a standard filling when:

  • The cavity is wide
  • Old fillings have broken down
  • The damage affects areas that take heavy chewing pressure

In these situations, a large filling may not provide enough long-term support. Over time, it can wear down, loosen, or allow the tooth to crack around it.

That’s often when a stronger option is considered.


Why a Crown Isn’t Always Necessary

Crowns are very effective restorations, but they involve reshaping the entire tooth so the crown can fit over it.

Sometimes that level of coverage is clearly needed. Other times, the tooth is still mostly healthy, and full coverage may remove more natural structure than necessary.

When damage is limited to a specific area and the rest of the tooth remains stable, dentists often look for a way to protect the tooth without going straight to a crown.


Where Inlays Fit In

Inlays are commonly recommended when a filling may be too weak, but a crown would be more than the tooth needs. Inlays are also used when preserving natural tooth structure is a priority.

In these situations, an inlay can:

  • Strengthen the damaged portion of the tooth
  • Help distribute chewing forces more evenly
  • Reduce stress on weakened areas
  • Protect the tooth without full coverage

Inlays offer a middle ground for treatment.


How Inlays Relate to Long-Term Value

Patients often ask how inlays compare to fillings or crowns in terms of cost. As with most things in dentistry, the answer depends on the tooth and the situation. But the cost often also is a middle-ground between fillings and crowns.

But beyond just the upfront cost, inlays hold a value for how well they support the tooth over time.

In some cases, inlays can:

  • Perform better than large fillings in stressed areas
  • Help reduce the risk of future fractures
  • Delay or prevent the need for more extensive treatment

While no one can fully know the future, inlays are generally a strong choice to balance durability, tooth preservation, and long-term maintenance.


Why Not Every Tooth Is a Good Candidate for an Inlay

Two teeth can look similar and still need different treatment.

Whether an inlay makes sense depends on:

  • How much healthy tooth remains
  • Where the damage is located
  • How much force the tooth takes during chewing
  • Bite alignment and habits
  • Long-term maintenance considerations

That’s why one tooth may be treated with an inlay, while another needs a crown—or only a filling.


Questions You Can Ask If an Inlay Is Recommended

If an inlay is suggested and you’re unsure, it’s reasonable to ask:

  • Why a filling isn’t strong enough in this case
  • Why a crown isn’t needed yet
  • How this option supports the tooth long-term

A clear explanation should help you understand how the recommendation fits into the overall health of the tooth—not just the repair itself.


The Bigger Picture

Inlays are one example of how dental treatment often falls between extremes.

They’re used when the goal is to:

  • Protect a weakened tooth
  • Preserve as much natural structure as possible
  • Reduce future risk
  • Choose a treatment that fits the situation rather than defaulting to the largest option

Understanding options like inlays can make dental decisions feel clearer and more collaborative.


Clinical reference

Research in restorative dentistry has shown that indirect restorations such as inlays can provide improved strength and fracture resistance compared to large direct fillings in certain teeth, particularly in areas exposed to higher chewing forces.

One commonly cited review:

  • Magne P, Belser U. Porcelain versus composite inlays/onlays: effects on stress distribution and tooth structure. Journal of Adhesive Dentistry.

Clinical decisions always depend on the specific tooth and patient factors.


Next steps

If you’re considering dental treatment and want to understand how recommendations are made, learning what to expect can help. You can find more information on our New Patients page.


Final note

This information is general and intended to explain how dentists think about inlays as part of treatment planning. Every tooth and every patient is different, and recommendations should always be based on your individual condition and a discussion with your dentist.

OFFICE

Carrollton Dentistry — Quality dental care you can trust.

1628 W Hebron Pkwy, Suite 108
Carrollton, TX 75010

Mon–Fri: 9AM–5PM
Sat–Sun: Closed

CONNECT WITH US

We accept major PPO plans including Aetna, Cigna, MetLife, and UnitedHealthcare. We also offer in-house membership plans.

Call: (972) 492-0002